As an affiliate for various programs such as Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission on some of the purchases you make at no extra cost to you. Read my disclaimer here.

I've owned a pair of Quoddy's Maliseet Oxford for a couple of years now, and they are pretty much the only pair presentable-looking shoes I own amidst a sea of sneakers and boots not suitable for formal attire. So when a hole slowly surfaced on the Vibram sole, I knew it was time to access repair options. I have always favored repairing over getting a new pair of anything. You spend a fraction in order to get to use the item again, as well as reduce your footprint on the earth.

L1150033 L1150036 L1150045 L1150048
This used to be an ad.

But no one likes ads, so I got rid of them. If my articles helped you, I ask for your support so I can continue to provide unbiased reviews and recommendations.

By becoming a Patreon, you get

  • Exclusive deals and coupons
  • Insider news to product releases and sales
  • Personalized style advice

Since skilled craftsmen are abundant in Japan, I considered getting repairs done locally to save on shipping costs. But Kirsten at Quoddy gave me a one-time offer to pay for the return shipping if I chose to do my repairs with them, which I gladly accepted. I always try to get my repairs done with the original manufacturer whenever possible.

If you choose to go to your local cobbler, Kirsten did offer the option to sell a pair of sole, which any cobbler with a Littleway sole-stitcher can use to replace the soles with.

If you decide to go with a local cobbler’s sole and service, the only instructions we have is that the soles are indeed stitched on…. so when removing s/he should take care not to scratch the leather bottom of the shoes. Also, most important, s/he should choose a sole which has the same or wider stitching groove… otherwise the stitching groove may be misplaced, resulting in visible unwanted holes from the first stitching seam.

After about 3 weeks, my Oxfords came back nicely in a nice Quoddy cloth bag. As expected from Quoddy, the resole was beautifully done and they look as good as new. The service, which costs US$79 came with cleaning and conditioning of the leather uppers as well. Definitely looking forward to more years of wear on these babies! Just see for yourselves.

L1150103 L1150106 L1150110


I was estatic with my new repairs. Till I put them on. The front of my right sole came out after literally 10 steps in them. It seems that there was a tear on the shoe where the stitching of the sole to the leather is. I contacted Quoddy and they said that it was a problem with their littleway machine. I would have expected them to do a check before sending it back. But my disappointment was quenched by their offer to send me a new pair, in any configuration I wanted.

I designed a thing.
Responsive image

I found a 100 year old company that would create these heirloom quality canisters for me. They are handmade and will keep your tea leaves, coffee beans or anything that you need dry for years to come.

or read review

I went for a change in color and a luxurious inner lining. While the old shoe was beyond repair as stitching the sole back was no longer possible, I used a good amount of shoe goo to give it a few more wears for old times' sake.


Tagged leather quoddy shoe